Canon : Events that actually take place within the
context of
the show(s).
Fanon : events that are written in fan fiction that don't
occur in
the show(s), but catch on in popularity and become a standard within
fan
fiction itself.
Fanon vs. Reality
e know the
definitions
and as writers, we often visit both sides of the issue when we
construct
a story. Canon is what gives us a basis for our fan fiction, but it's
often
fanon that shapes whole genres of fandom. A certain trait or
personality
quirk of a character is emphasized and repeated over and over because
writers
find it desirable or perhaps think it defines the character in some
way,
regardless of whether or not it was a frequent occurrence in canon.
(Examples
can be made of Spike's supposed love of marshmallows in Buffy the
Vampire
Slayer, Methos throwing beer tabs behind Macleod's fridge in Highlander,
and Cupid's jealous transformation into a green eyed monster on Hercules
the Legendary Journeys. These are all things that rarely happened
--
perhaps only once -- in canon, but occur constantly in fan fiction.)
There
are times, however, when fanon is inspired by fan fiction itself, as is
the case in the Hercules-Xena-Young Hercules
fandom.
Some years back, three writers took a
chance and wrote an
odd paring:
Ares/Joxer. The two characters hadn't shared much screen time and what
they had wasn't exactly overflowing with chemistry. Those writers took
a shot though and for a long time it looked as though they'd be all
alone
in their strange tastes. Then they began to slowly attract notice and
the
pairing took on a life of its own as more and more writers attempted
it.
A few years ago, an author wrote a new
characterization
of Ares.
She stated that the story took place in an alternate world so as to
excuse
Ares' rather odd behavior, and since it was a completely new
characterization
at the time, no one thought it particularly bad. It was simply...new.
In
this story, Ares was a kinder, gentler version of the God of War we'd
come
to know on the shows, as were most of his family. He had a caring,
loving
side which he lavished on Joxer, his new lover. Everything was
blissful,
mushy happiness and there wasn't anything necessarily wrong with that.
Around the same time another author wrote
a little story
wherein Cupid and
Strife
got together for a little bit of PWP fun. Two characters who'd never
shared screen time; it was a novel idea but it didn't receive
overwhelming support. At first.
What do these anecdotes have in common?
The fact that they
were all
the spawning points for fanon convention. Once Ares/Joxer caught on,
there
was no stopping it. At the same time, although they were far slower to
develop, the new "fluffy" version of Ares and the pairing of
Cupid/Strife
began to gain popularity. When the three finally met, it was a
collision
of massive fanon that resulted in what has since become a mind boggling
overflow of badfic.
What makes this badfic? Certainly not any
singular one of
those elements,
or even those elements at all, it's what's been done with them that
crossed
the boundary. When every male in the story bursts into tears at a
moment's
notice; when gods we know as a fact from canon to be bad
guys/girls,
are suddenly misunderstood fluffy good guys in black leather with no
good explanation; when the good guys/girls suddenly turn into
bigoted,
small-minded dolts; when the characters start talking in
incomprehensible
accents; when every female canon love interest is turned into a
manipulative
bitch just to get her out of the way of m/m true love; when love just
isn't
considered true love or even true marriage unless the man gets
pregnant; that
is when you either have a truly hilarious parody, or an extremely
horrific
badfic.
This is probably a good point to discuss
the concept of
"stylistic"
or "creative" characterization versus plain old bad writing.
The defense of so many of the authors who
pen badfic is that
this is
their "vision" of the characters, or that since this is their story,
they
can do whatever they want and it's not wrong. Of course an author has
the
right to write whatever characterization they feel like, it's called
"free
will," but that doesn't make it good writing either. These aren't
"characterizations,"
they're "caricatures," or, to use a fan fiction term, the characters
are
severely OOC (out of character). The reply of many serious authors to
these
claims of "vision" and "it's my story" is simply, why write fan
fiction? If someone is that set on writing characters that bear no
resemblance
to the ones in the shows, then why not simply write an original story?
Why turn good characters into parodies of themselves? It's just plain
bad
writing.
Let's cover a few fanon conventions now,
and what makes them
so horrific
to serious fan fiction authors.
Ares, God of War, fanon:
- He's really a very kind and gentle person who's either been
forced into
his position by Zeus and hates it, or he does his job as carefully as
possible
because Greece needs war to keep the population in check, and he always
goes out of his way to make sure "innocents" aren't hurt.
- Ares cries without reservations.
- He refers to his lover by extremely sappy nicknames (i.e.
sweetheart,
darling,
honey).
- He becomes pregnant and carries it by conventional mortal
means (sex,
morning
sickness, nine months, etc.).
Ares, God of War, canon:
- He is a Very Bad God. (Note the capitals.) Not only is Ares
very happy
with his job, he revels in it. He starts wars for the fun of it and
killing
innocent people is a great game for him, especially when he knows he
can
use it to manipulate the good guys.
- Ares is in no way fluffy or sweet. He can be seductive and
sexy, but
that
does not automatically equate to good.
- The Ares we know in canon would never allow himself
to become
pregnant
like some mere mortal. If, on the extremely off chance he did become
pregnant,
he likely would aborted it or carry it by some godly, unconventional
method.
Either way, he most likely would not be happy about it.
Joxer, fanon:
- He's usually one of two things, a mortal who's been
horribly and
deliberately
abused and neglected by his father and friends, or a demi-god who's
secretly
working for his godly parent, usually Strife, against Xena and
Hercules.
- He's highly intelligent, handsome, and sometimes secretly
an expert
warrior.
- He's usually one of Ares' most devoted worshipers.
- He overcomes his love for Gabrielle, or realizes he never
truly loved
her
because she treats him so badly.
- He ends up as Ares' husband and as a peaceful, and often
pregnant,
god.
- He's the solution to saving the world.
Joxer, canon:
- Joxer might've been neglected by his father, but there was
never any
real
sign of abuse.
- Joxer is not conventionally handsome and he's
extremely far
from
being anything resembling a good warrior; he's a clumsy, not so bright
doofus, basically.
- Joxer loves Gabrielle, really loves her, even when
he's sleeping
with Meg. Joxer may be deluded about many things in life, but his
feelings
for Gabrielle aren't one of them.
- There's never any mention of Joxer's religious leanings but
it has been
stated and shown in more than one episode that Ares thinks Joxer is a
worthless
excuse for a warrior.
- Joxer is the key to saving the world at least once, but
it's with the
help
of his friends; he's never the solo act.
Strife, God of Mischief, fanon:
- He is referred to constantly as the "God of Mischief."
- His real name is often not "Strife" but "Erin."
- His real job has next to nothing to do with serious
trouble; he really
focuses on "harmless" things like jokes and children. In fact, Strife
loves
children.
- He's only mildly naughty and not really a bad guy at
all.
- Discord either abused him horribly as a child and Ares
raised him, or
Discord
is the most loving mother he could ever have had.
- He talks with an nearly incomprehensible accent, a mix of
valley and
inner
city, wherein he hardly enunciates a single word that comes out of his
mouth.
- He's severely lonely and in love secretly with Cupid.
- He becomes Cupid's husband and has Cupid's child.
Strife, canon:
- He has never once been referred to as the "God of
Mischief." Strife
certainly
never refers to himself by that title and in fact, seems to be angling
for a better job.
- Strife is never credited with any other name. ("Erin" is in
fact, a
historically
female name as well as being another name for Ireland.)
- Strife tries his very best to cause the worst damage
possible, in the
most
harmful manner he can come up with. He's a screw up, true, but when he
gets things right, it's bad news for his target. (Anyone remember
Serena?)
- He's shown no remorse about killing innocent mortals and
shows no
particular
interest in children.
- There has never once been any mention of Strife's
parentage. We know
Ares
is his uncle, but even in Young Hercules, he never called
Discord,
"mother." We do know from the dialogue that she's older than him by a
millennium,
but their interaction is more along the lines of sibling rivalry than
it
is parent/child.
- Strife enunciates his words clearly without a "ya" or "tha"
or
"nothin'"
in sight.
- Strife never meets Cupid on the show and seems to get his
base needs
fulfilled
just fine by various minor goddesses or priestesses, judging from the
episodes
"Encounter" and "Treasure of Zeus."
- The likelihood of Strife becoming pregnant is probably
somewhere up
there
with the odds of the Earth stopping dead in its orbit right this
instant.
Cupid, God of Love, fanon:
- Big, buff, and broken hearted, Cupid is one hunk-o-angst.
Torn up by
Psyche's
betrayal of him -- pick a method; she betrays him somehow -- he's now
pining
away over his cousin, Strife.
- In many, if not all cases, Cupid has always loved Strife
and marrying
Psyche
was a mistake because, 1) he shot himself with his own arrow, or 2) he
thought he couldn't have Strife so he turned to Psyche and thought it
was
love.
- He's quick to drop Psyche from his life at the first show
of interest
from
Strife.
- He's a young god who grew up with Strife.
- He's taller than Strife.
- His main goals in life are to raise his son Bliss and to
make Strife
his
happy hubby.
Cupid, God of Love, canon:
- He is definitely a big hunk-o-broodiness the first time we
meet him,
but
that's because he's dealing with unrequited love. Cupid has one Love of
His Life™. Her name is Psyche. He pines after her on the show,
turns
into
a green eyed monster out of jealousy over her, and even defies his
mother
to prove that he loves Psyche. The next time we see Cupid, he's
perfectly
happy with Psyche and Bliss, no sign of marital problems at all.
- Cupid was never once shown on the same screen, or even in
the same
episode
as Strife.
- Karl Urban, the actor who plays Cupid, is 6'1", the exact
same height
as
Joel Tobeck, the actor who plays Strife. Cupid is slightly more
muscular
than Strife, but not by much. Cupid is far less built than Ares, for
instance.
- We have no idea how old Cupid is from the show, although
it's safe to
say
he's younger than Aphrodite. In mythology, however, many myths state
that
he's one of the first gods. Either way, it's very doubtful he's as
young
as Strife, or even grew up with him.
Psyche, fanon:
- Manipulative, cheating, scheming, cold-hearted, uber-bitch.
She marries
Cupid just to become a goddess and doesn't love him at all. She's bored
with him and seeks out other gods to entertain her in the bedroom.
- She's emotionally abusive to Cupid and sometimes Bliss as
well.
- She doesn't love Bliss and is a horrible mother.
- She sometimes uses magical means to keep Cupid infatuated
with
her.
- She hates Strife because she knows Cupid loves him.
- She's looking for the first opportunity to divorce Cupid,
retain her
godhood,
and move to some more powerful god's bed.
- If she's ever referred to by her proper title, "Goddess of
the Mind,"
there's
usually another title attached, "and Manipulation," or something
similar
to "explain" her bitchiness.
Psyche, Goddess of the Mind, canon:
- There isn't much we really know about her from the show,
other than the
fact that she does love Cupid and they're happy together. It's
mythology
that really blows the fanon version of her out of the water. Psyche not
only loves Cupid, she loves him so much that she goes through hell for
him -- literally, folks; the woman walks into Tartarus for a
chance
to be reunited with Cupid.
- If she's ever manipulative, it's to get revenge on her vain
and jealous
sisters who push her into looking at Cupid's face -- something he'd
forbidden
-- which drives him away from her. She makes her sisters pay for that,
but what woman wouldn't?
- Psyche does everything she can to prove herself to both
Cupid and
Aphrodite,
and by all accounts she was a model mother to the children she bore
Cupid.
- This is a strong, loving woman, not some two-dimensional
tramp, and she
only ever had one title, "Goddess of the Mind."
Gabrielle, fanon:
- Backstabbing, close-minded, abusive bitch. She cares for no
one but
herself
and treats everyone like dirt, especially Joxer. She goes out of her
way
to insult Joxer, hit him, put him down in every way possible just so
she
can feel better about herself.
- When Joxer inevitably realizes he doesn't love her -- it's
always
inevitable
in these stories -- she's furious that he's out of her grasp because
now
he no longer devotes all his affections and desire to her, as she
believes
is her right.
- When everyone in the story is fighting to save the world,
Gabrielle is
likely to switch her loyalties to the other side simply because she's
really
an evil, self-centered bitch.
Gabrielle, canon:
- Not only does Gabrielle care about others, she sometimes
has the fault
of caring too much, especially in the first couple seasons. She
often puts herself, and yes, others as well, in danger because she
cares
so much about doing the right thing that she doesn't see the danger
until
it's almost too late, or at times she simply can't avoid the danger.
She
does become more responsible through the years, more capable too and is
able to help without causing problems for everyone.
- Both she and Xena are very good friends to Joxer. Sometimes
they ignore
him and yes, Gabrielle does smack him a few times, but keep in mind how
insulting and outright annoying Joxer is much of the time; she reacts
appropriately
most times. It's made obvious in many episodes how much they really do
care for Joxer as a friend, and indeed, sometimes how much they do
ignore
him, but it's never malicious neglect.
- Gabrielle does some wrong things, saving Hope, allying
herself with
Ares
to get to Chin before Xena, but always because she's trying to work
towards
the greater good. She never means for things to go wrong, even if in
the
end, they do. Gabrielle is by no means perfect, but she isn't one of
the
bad guys either, not by a long shot.
Xena, Warrior Princess, fanon:
- Xena is one of the few characters that the badfic writers
don't warp
too
badly. She always remains one of the good guys and a caring, strong
person.
However, the fanon Xena is blind to Gabrielle's self-centered mean
ways.
- She's also blind to the fact that war is necessary; despite
being a
warlord
herself for years, it never once occurs to her that war is needed to
control
the excess mortal population, to avoid starvation, to let off
aggression,
to [insert excuse here]. Not until Ares, Joxer, Strife, or someone of
that
"House" explains it to her does she begin to grasp the concept.
- She is always Ares' daughter.
Xena, Warrior Princess, canon:
- Xena is neither stupid nor clueless, nor is she blind. She
loves
Gabrielle
as her closest friend (and yes, a case can be made for another type of
love), and not only is she well aware of Gabrielle's flaws, she helps
Gabrielle
to overcome them, to be a better, stronger person by example.
- Xena would never travel with someone who was as
deliberately mean and
cruel
as the fanon Gabrielle is made out to be, and Xena would certainly
never
call someone like that a friend.
- Xena is well aware of the nature of war, having waged it
herself for
years.
The wars she has stopped over the years are random violence, little
more
than an entertainment for Ares, or they were senseless squabbles over
territory
between powerful mortals. She does good deeds in stopping these
wars.
- She is also not Ares' daughter. That was a trick Xena
pulled on the
Furies
to stop them from punishing her for killing her real father. Neither
she
nor Ares really believe that he is her father, as was shown in numerous
episodes.
Hercules, fanon:
- Knuckle-dragging, pig-headed, stick up his ass, moron. He
is blind to
the
true, caring nature of the gods, except for Zeus, whom he believes to
be
a just, loving person when in reality, Zeus is an evil, manipulative
rapist/psycho.
- Hercules goes around mindlessly stopping "needed" wars and
spreading
false,
ugly rumors about his poor, maligned half-brother, Ares.
- He believes that the only goal Ares and Strife have is to
cause him and
his loved ones harm. He refuses to believe that Ares and Strife are
actually
kind, loving gods who are just misunderstood.
- Hercules is quick to turn on anyone who doesn't share his
beliefs.
Hercules, canon:
- He's very much aware of the true nature of the gods,
namely, that some
of them are nice -- so far as powerful beings with little understanding
of human mortality can be, some of them are neutral, and some of them
are
outright evil. Ares and Strife fall under the latter category, and
Hercules
knows this.
- He also knows that Zeus is a god with severe flaws and
there's no love
lost between them. He does wish for a better relationship with his
father,
but he knows it can never happen until Zeus learns a better (more
human)
sense of morality and values.
- Hercules fights in wars when it's necessary and stops them
when they
aren't
necessary. He doesn't do it arbitrarily.
- He is by no means an idiot or a bigot; he tolerates other
people's
beliefs
and points of views just fine, so long as it's not hurting anyone.
"House of War" (or Love, or
Intellect, or Death), fanon:
- No one is too sure where this came from. The gods are
separated into
houses.
Ares, Discord, Strife and all the "War" gods are put into the House of
War. Aphrodite, Cupid and Bliss are in the House of Love. Apollo,
Athena,
Psyche and others fit into the House of Intellect. Hades and other
Underworld
gods go into Death. It's a toss up as to where all the other gods are;
it depends on the author. These designations give all the gods fixed
jobs,
it also helps the author and reader fit the gods into a certain
"place,"
a frame of reference. Everything is all neat and tidy on Olympus with
the
Houses.
"House of whatever," canon:
- Doesn't exist. That's right; it. Does. Not. Exist. And why
would it?
Why
would a god need to be pigeon-holed into a slot? How could it
even
be done with some of the gods? What about ones like Hephaestus? Where
does
he fit? Or Dionysus? Or Poseidon? And what about gods like Persephone?
Ones who live in one place but are associated with another? Where do
they
fit? That's the problem with this method of classification; it simply doesn't
work. There's no need for it either. If one god thinks another is
infringing
on his/her territory, they can sort it out between them, no need for
designated
"Houses."
Mpreg, fanon:
- Every guy is a baby machine. Ares is waddling around nine
months gone,
Strife has morning sickness and Joxer is getting chubby.
- Every time a guy, god or not, gets knocked up, they have
all the
classical
symptoms of female human pregnancy.
- Pregnancy is the catalyst for two of the love interests
getting
married,
or it's what makes them realize they love each other, or it's a
horrible
crisis for the pregnant guy until he realizes how wonderful it is and
that
he really does love his boyfriend.
- It's always an accident.
- A kind of sidebar to this category is male breastfeeding.
Once the male
character(s) have given birth, they then breastfeed their child just
like
a normal human woman. The other case is usually Cupid breastfeeding
Bliss
after Psyche has abandoned them.
Mpreg, canon:
- Once again, this does. Not. Happen.
At least
not the
way it's normally written in badfic. Why would it? Why would a god
decided to become pregnant? Which brings up a good point; these are gods,
very powerful beings who most likely have absolute control over their
reproductive
process. There is no way a god could become pregnant by
accident.
This would have to be a planned thing. And assuming for some reason one
did become pregnant, why would it ever resemble a human
pregnancy?
- Morning sickness is a woman's immune system responding to
what it
perceives
as a parasitic invasion. Going by that scientific fact, why would a god
ever have morning sickness? Assuming they even have an immune system,
wouldn't
they just repress it? The same can be said for all the "classical"
symptoms
such as swollen feet, bad backs and weight gain; a god would simply will
those things not to happen.
- And what's to say a god would carry a child for nine
months? Why not
nine
years? Or nine days? And why must it always be a baby? Athena sprung
from
Zeus' head fully grown and armed for battle; Dionysus was stitched into
Zeus' thigh for three months and when the stitches were removed, he was
fully formed, so why wouldn't a god give birth to a grown
god/dess?
- Wouldn't the child have some say over the manner of their
birth, given
that they too are a god/dess?
- For another point, since when does becoming pregnant equate
to true
love?
How does bearing a child mean that you truly love someone? It doesn't.
Pregnancy is not a way to prove love and it is not the inevitable
conclusion
to marriage.
- Why would a god need to breastfeed a baby? Have wet nurses
suddenly
become
extinct? What's wrong with good old goat's milk? For that matter, why
would
baby gods need milk to begin with? Don't gods eat ambrosia?
- These are logical, fact and mythology-based questions and
statements
that
are never addressed in fanon badfic.
The differences between fanon and canon
here is not only extreme but very
obvious as well. So obvious that it should be simple enough to avoid
the
pitfalls of fanon. Unfortunately, what's occurred over the past few
years is basically a vicious cycle.
Someone new comes into the Herc-Xena
fandom and sees
all of this
badfic -- it's hard to miss since it's so prolific these days. That
person
decides to try their hand at writing, either never having seen a single
episode of the shows themselves, or not having seen them since the last
new episodes ran. Since their memories of the shows are fuzzy or
nonexistent,
they assume that this massive quantity of fic must reflect the reality
of the show, i.e., canon. After all, the body of badfic out there is
pretty
much the same plot and ideas just written slightly differently each
time.
It's easy for a newcomer to be confused and take it for canon.
So this newbie writes a story. Maybe it
has potential, maybe
it's utter
crap, but it really doesn't matter because when it's posted to the
right
list -- one that devours fanon badfic like candy -- it'll be met with
choruses
of, "omg thats so gret i luv yor fic youl rit mor wont u???!!one!!!"
Regardless
of the quality of the fic, that is the response it will receive. Some
responses
will contain a better knowledge of the English language and others will
be more dreadful netspeak, but they will all have one thing in common,
they will demand more fanon badfic. No one will ever give an author
constructive
criticism. No one will point out bad spelling, punctuation or grammar.
No one will give advice on constructing a better plot, better
description
or dialogue. There will simply be a demand for more, more, more.
Give us more crap because we can't tell the difference between that and
the actual good fic.
With that kind of response, no author is
ever given the
incentive to
improve. No author has any way of knowing they need to improve.
There's an audience for complete trash and that's all any author has to
write to receive mindless feedback. It's an extremely sad direction
that
section of the fandom has turned towards and it shows no sign of
letting
up, but there is still the occasional author out there who somehow
finds
their way out of that bog of stench, or authors who are trying
desperately
to never venture anywhere near it. It's not the easy road to chose, but
if you take pride in your work, it's the higher road.
Now, unfortunately fanfic authors can't
live by canon alone,
and any
author in this fandom who swears they've never used a single fanon
convention
probably needs to go back and reread their own work. Everyone uses
them.
The difference is, serious authors don't rely on those
conventions
for the entire development of their characters. Canon is referred to
far
more often, and mythology even more so. Serious authors strive for new
and different looks at the characters, their characterizations and
histories;
they don't write stories with other fanfic as their sole basis and
reference.
That way lies badfic.
Technical Writing Mistakes
very author
has their
own writing style and while there's nothing wrong with that, there are
some things, technical aspects, that are wrong. What follows
are
some examples of the wrong way to do things, and explanations of what
makes
them incorrect.
"Yea. I'm like, so.so **_IN_**
**_LOVE_** with you!!!!!!"
Cupid growled.
Okay, what's wrong with the above
sentence?
1) Let's start with the first thing. "Yea"
rhymes with, "nay."
It's
an archaic expression now used almost solely in the legal system or in
formal proceedings during voting. (i.e. "When your name is called,
state
'yea' or 'nay' on the proposal.")
The word that should be at the beginning
of that sentence is,
"Yeah."
It rhymes somewhat with, "Nah." "Yeah" is a slang form of the word,
"yes"
that we use in America, although its use has likely spread far outside
our borders.
2) The second thing wrong with this
sentence is the lack of
ellipses.
"so.so" should be written as, "so...so" because the standard
punctuation
mark for a pause in speech is a set of three periods, in other words,
ellipses.
3) Thirdly, there is absolutely no need to
slap that
much emphasis
on any word. Not only does it look bad, it's technically incorrect.
Instead
of, "**_IN_**," it should read, "*in*." For both words, "**_IN_**
**_LOVE_**,"
should be reduced to, "*in love*." Using the asterisks around both
words
cuts down on the clutter of having four of them in there while still
getting
across the emphasis. Capitalization is also unnecessary if you're going
to use another form of emphasis with it. Choose one or the other, not
both.
4) Overpunctuation is the catch word for
the day here. There
is no excuse
for using more than one set of punctuation marks. "you!!!!!!" should
be,
"you!" And if that isn't enough emphasis, then it can be written as,
"*you*!"
to get it across. The same goes for anything in this line: "?!?!?!" or
"??????" or any other set of multiple punctuations. Chose one and stick
with it. Find another way to place emphasis on words if you need to.
5) "Cupid growled." Okay, when was the
last time you
growled
out an entire sentence? Try it sometime, you'll sound like an idiot and
probably end up with a sore throat on top of it. Face it, we don't talk
that way. We don't hiss whole sentences, sneer them, sniff them, or sob
them. Therefore, the only way to phrase the last part of the sentence
so
that it makes sense, is like this: "Cupid said with a growl." Or some
variant
thereof. Cupid can still growl, but he's not going to be growling the
sentence.
Here's the entire sentence, corrected:
"Yeah. I'm like, so...so *in love* with
you!" Cupid said
with a growl.
Now for a little something different.
The smaller man looked up at Hercules
and the demi-god
frowned. Iolaus
shook his head. The larger man sighed in resignation and the blond
hunter
grinned, knowing he'd won the argument with the stronger man.
Here are a few things to cut out of your
vocabulary when you
write:
"the man/woman/god(dess)," "the smaller/larger man/woman/god(dess),"
"the
[insert hair/eye color here] man/woman/god(dess)," "the other
man/woman/god(dess),"
"the younger/older man/woman/god(dess)," "the demi-god," "the hunter,"
"the Warrior Princess," "the Amazon," "the bard," "the
wannabe-warrior,"
"the thief," "the [insert title here] God(dess)," or any
variation
thereof. These titles are known as "epithets" and they are evil.
When you use epithets such as "the hunter"
for Iolaus or "the
bard"
for Gabrielle, you're doing them an injustice. You're
compartmentalizing
them. By referring to them or any other character in that fashion,
you're
stating that those descriptions are all those characters are.
You're
saying that Iolaus is a hunter and nothing else, that Gabrielle is a
bard
twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week; it's an erroneous statement
because we know none of those to be the case.
Iolaus is a hunter, true, but he's also a
tracker, a soldier,
a smith,
a friend, a hero, a fighter, and so many other things that it's
pointless
to try to pigeon-hole his character. The same is true for Gabrielle;
she's
a bard, an Amazon princess, a sister, a widow, and much, much more.
Every
single character from Zeus down to Falafel can be described in
multitudes
of different ways, none of which should be used in place of a pronoun
or
their proper names.
The corrected sentence:
Iolaus looked up at Hercules who
frowned at him. Iolaus
shook his
head. Hercules sighed in resignation and Iolaus grinned, knowing he'd
won
the argument.
And for another example:
"I toldjya ta take tha knife 'n
getchyer ass outta here,
Cupid! Whatchya
still doin' here?" Strife asked.
As mentioned in the above discussion of
characterization,
Strife has
never once in any of the episodes in which he appeared,
talked
in any way like the above sentence. Strife actually enunciates
his
words extremely well. Go back and watch his scenes, rerun the tape over
and over and I promise you not once will you hear a "yer," "tha," "'n,"
or "ya." The only way Strife talks differently from the other gods is
by
inserting slang into his speech. That's what Ares' complaints are about
where Strife's manner of talking is concerned.
What makes Strife such an odd character
isn't just his use of
slang,
it's his body language. He moves differently from
anyone
else. What he says with words is nothing compared to what his body is
saying.
His movements are exaggerated, almost flamboyant at times. It seems
that
many authors have no way of either understanding this or expressing it
through writing, so they give him a bad accent instead to make him
stand
out.
To reiterate, Strife does not speak
like an inner
city reject.
He doesn't drop the "g" off of his words, he says "you" just fine, as
well
as "and," "to," and "your." He doesn't run his words together. There
are
no "getchyer," "didn'tchya," "wantchya," or any other such phrases in
his
speech. He does, however, use the occasional "gonna" and
"wanna,"
as do most of the characters on the shows, but "kinda," "sorta," and
"outta"
are much more rare. You can't use them constantly.
Writing Strife with a horrendous accent is
not only
technically wrong,
it's a pain for readers to understand. When someone has to stop reading
a fic and spend time trying to translate a character's speech, that's a
sign that something is very wrong. Dialect can be good for showing that
a character is from someplace foreign, or grew up in a different area
of
town, but it should never be taken to the extremes badfic!Strife has.
And
there's no excuse for writing dialect for Strife anyway, not when canon
clearly shows us that he speaks very normally, probably even more
correctly
than your average American, even with the slang.
The corrected sentence:
"I told you to take the knife and get
your ass outta here,
Cupid!
What're you still doing here?" Strife asked.
Just a few quick technical lessons to
think about.
Links to other helpful essays and rants on
this subject
The
Big List of Fanfic Peeves
Commonly
Confused Words and Their Meanings
fanficrants:
Lack of Punctuation is NOT "Stylistic"
Fanfic
Symposium: Banishing the Wild Epithet
S/X
and Violence: Tiny Marshmallows Want to be Free
Overuse of one-off plot points -- turning canon into fanon, by Mer
Thamiris'
Sexed Up Grammar Guide
The Transitive
Demigod
How not to write: links to
deliberate badfic
"Dial
S for Stupid," by Beth
"Kiss,
Kiss, Bang, Bang," by Thamiris
The Less Than
Legendary
Journeys: Guide to Writing in the HtLJ Universe
"Love's
Conquering Light," by Arabella
"Pair of Fools," by Candace
and Erin
"Sweat Blazing Desire,"
by Erin
Thanks so much to Candace for looking over this for me. All
remaining
mistakes are my bad.
Credit goes to Roo
for the arguments she presented on the "Houses" and male breastfeeding
issues in her rant
on the LJ, The
Temple of Bad Herc-Xena Fanfic. Also thanks to Mary
Crawford for the reminder about Dionysus' circumstances of birth.
mythdefied@gmail.com